Home
Biography
Building Statistics
Thesis Abstract
Technical Assignments
Research
Thesis Proposal
Presentation
Final Report
E-Studio
Reflection

User Note:

While great efforts have been taken to provide accurate and complete information on the pages of CPEP, please be aware that the information contained herewith is considered a work-in-progress for this thesis project. Modifications and changes related to the original building designs and construction methodologies for this senior thesis project are solely the interpretation of Nicholas Umosella. Changes and discrepancies in no way imply that the original design contained errors or was flawed. Differing assumptions, code references, requirements, and methodologies have been incorporated into this thesis project; therefore, investigation results may vary from the original design.

 
This page was last updated on October 2, 2009 by Nicholas Umosella and is hosted by the AE Department © 2009
-Building Statistics-
 
General Building Statistics
Building Name:
West Village Commons At Towson University
 
Location and Site:
Located on the western edge of campus between the Paca and Tubman residence halls. The top 2 floors span over Emerson Road. The address for West Village Commons is:

424 Emerson Drive
Towson, Maryland, 21204
 
Fig. 1: Google Map of Site, maps.google.com
 
Fig. 2: Satellite Image of Site, maps.google.com
Occupancy Type:
Mixed use dining and organizational meeting facility
Size:
85,000 SF
4 story plus basement
67 feet from finish grade (tallest elevation)
Dates of Construction:
July 15, 2009 to February 28, 2011 (substantial completion)
Project Delivery Mode:
Design-Bid-Build
Contractual Method:
Construction Manager at Risk with GMP
GMP:
$30,381,994.00
Project Team
Owner:
Towson University
Architect:
GWWO Inc./Architects
Construction Manager:
Barton Malow Company
Structural Engineer:
ReSTL Engineers
MEP Engineer:
James Posey Associates, Inc.
Civil Engineer:
Site Resources Inc.
Lighting Design:
Bruce Dunlop Lighting Design, LLP
Landscape Architect:
Mahan Rykiel Associates
Interior Design Consultant:
PLDA, Inc.
Food Service Design:
Ricca Newmark Design
Architecture

Design Components:

The West Village Commons Building was designed with the intent of becoming the gateway to the west side of campus. It will be the home to many mixed use amenities. The first floor will house a grocery store, ATMs, and specialty take-out food shops. A dining hall is located on the second floor which will provide buffet style meals to the students in the surrounding residence halls. The third floor will contain an exercise room and support offices, while the fourth floor will mainly be used as large multi-purpose and gathering spaces. Figures 3, 4, and 5 to the right are schematic floor plans.

The third and fourth floor of the new facility span over the recently completed Emerson Drive. This bridge like structure (see Fig. 6 and 7) provides an architectural focus for students and faculty when entering the West Village area of campus. The site design provides eye-catching landscape, adding to its green design.

Note: The figures to the right were early design ideas. They are meant to show the building footprint and overall form.

 

Fig. 3: Commons Level Plan, GWWO

Applicable Codes

      • Building code jurisdiction: State of Maryland
      • Health code jurisdiction: Baltimore County Maryland
      • 2006 International Building Code
      • 2006 Life Safety Code – NFPA 101
      • 2006 Fire Protection Code – NFPA 1
      • 2006 International Mechanical Code
      • 2006 International Standard Plumbing Code
      • 2006 International Standard Electrical Code
      •  Maryland Accessibility Code – COMAR 05.02.02
      • Flood Plan Regulations
Fig. 4: Street and Third Level Plan, GWWO
  Fig. 5: Fourth and Roof Level Plan, GWWO
Building Enclosure

Building Facade:

The exterior of the West Village commons has a spectacular amount of glass curtainwall area. It serves as not only a keynote architectural feature, but also a means of allowing much needed daylighting to gathering areas and dining halls. Several different wall types keep the West Village Commons enclosed. Brick masonry and zinc sheet metal panels combine for the wall construction. The curtain wall, made up of individual window glazing and spandral panels, spans the third and fourth floor floor bridge on the south end and the entire north elevation is made up of a spandel glass of varying transparancies held together with aluminum framing. Figure 6 is an early rendering of the building exterior, and Figure 7 is the final design.

Roofing:

The roofing consist of a two different systems. The first one is a thermoplastic polyoledin (TPO) single-ply membrane (ASTM 6878-03). This type covers the majority of the roof over the fourth floor and the west side of the partial third floor roof. The second type is a green roof system which consists of a hot fluid-applied, rubberized-asphalt waterproofing membrane, sheet metal flashing, a filter fabric, and a drainage/water retention subsection. The green roof system tops the area of the third floor that steps back on the east side. The green roof will be accessible to the public and will support rigorous vegetation.

 

Fig. 6: Early Design Rendering, GWWO
 
Fig. 7: Final Design Renderin, GWWO
Sustainable Features

In August of 2007, President Caret of Towson University announced that all new building projects and renovations would pursue LEED certification. Towson is home to 47 buildings and over 4 million square feet of building space, having a huge impact on energy use. Towson's dedication to green buildings is shown off in the West Village Commons project as it is striving to achieve a LEED Silver Rating. The architect has stated that the West Commons Village could potentially be eligible for a Gold rating.

Some of the features include low-flow toilets, occupant lighting sensors, and water efficient landscaping. There is a green roof on the east side of the third floor allowing substantial vegetation to absorb rainwater. This green roof will be accessible to the public allowing a comfortable setting to relax while eating a meal or studying. (Note that Figure 8 has a green roof on the fourth floor, which is no longer the case. It is located on the third floor partial roof). The commons will also use regional materials, pre and post recycled materials, and FSC certified wood products. The large curtain wall will help passively heat the building in the winter months and allows adequite daylighting to most of the building's rooms. It is equipped with roller shades and louvres to help disipate the strong heat gains that the curtain wall will cause.

 
    Figure 8: Early Design Rendering (Exterior Facade has changed since), GWWO
Construction

The West Village Commons Project is a 20.5 month project in the heart of a condensed college campus. Site logistics become quite the issue on such a tight site while school is in session. Special care in timing loud construction processes during school hours is a tough issue to build a schedule around.

Barton Malow is utilizing a milestone project schedule with 21 milestone dates, and will be tracked using the critical path method. Documentation is tracked using Prolog Web with an effort to use the least amount of paper as necessary. Prolog Web is a database that allows a continued stream of information flow between parties in real time. RFI's, meeting minutes, etc... are posted directly onto the website and email notifications are sent out.

The Barton Malow Company is a dedicated industry leader on not only the utilization of BIM, but also the exploration of new construction technologies and techniques. West Village Commons is benefiting from several unique construction aspects. The chart below illustrates some of the techniques:

Building Information Model
Barton Malow is using Tekla Structures to model the structural concrete and steel. This will help in sequencing, coordination, and overall visualization of a complicated structural system. The Structural Concrete, Structural Steel, Mechanical/ Plumbing, Electrical, Fire Suppression, and Drywall Contractors will all be involved in coordination and trade work clash detection. The West Village Commons team will also use BIM for closeout/punchlist work.
Barton Malow/Maryland OSHA Partnership
Barton Malow and Maryland OSHA signed a partnership to work together to eliminate safety hazards at West Village Commons. This partnership is to help generate an information flow to workers on the job and help eliminate potentially harmful site risks.
Multivista Photograph Documentation
Online database of all site photos, linked to floor plans and areas.
25% Minority Business Enterprise
25% of the construction cost must be from a State of Maryland designated Minority Business Enterprise.

 

Towson University West Village Commons was bid out in two seperate packages so that site work, foundation, and initial cast-in-place structural concrete could begin early. Below is a break down of the two packages:

Bid Package "A"

  • Excavation, Earth Retention and Site Utilities
  • Deep Foundations (Rammed Stone Piers)
  • Arborist Services & Tree Preservation
  • Cast-in-Place Concrete & Waterproofing
  • Under-slab & Slab Penetrations for Mechanical, Plumbing & Fire Protection
  • Under-slab & Slab Penetrations for Electrical

GMP Package "A": $7,120,965 (Does not include preconstruction services)

Bid Package "B"

  • Finish Sitework
  • Landscaping & Topsoil Placement
  • Masonry
  • Structural Steel
  • Miscellaneous Metals
  • Ornamental Stairs & Rails
  • Millwork and Architectural Woodwork
  • Roofing & Rheinzink Cladding
  • Fireproofing
  • Windows, Entrances, Curtain Wall, & Metal Wall Panels
  • Interior Partitions and Ceilings
  • Ceramic Tile and Stone Flooring
  • Resilient Flooring and Carpet
  • Painting and Wall Covering
  • General Trades, Doors, Frames, & Hardware
  • Signage
  • Food Service Equipment
  • Elevators
  • Mechanical & Plumbing
  • Fire Protection
  • Electrical, Fire Alarm & Security

GMP Package "B": $22,691,029 (does not include preconstruction services)     

Structural System

http://www.geostructures.com/images/3-step-process.gifSubstructure:

The building's foundation system consists of spread footings on natural soil for the basement and Ram Aggregate Piers® (R.A.P. or  Geo Piers) for level 1. The piers have a bearing capacity of 6,000 ksf minimum and compacted fill with an allowable bearing capacity of 4,000 psf. To place the R.A.P.'s, first an auger is drilled to the geotechnical specified depth. Stone is placed in 12" lifts and pounded by an excavator equipped with a hydraulic break hammer. See Figure 9 for a cross-sectional view of the process. When properly placed, these piers not only allow direct structural support, but also strengthen the surrounding soil. With a foundation loads greater than 3,000 kips, the system will limit foundation settlement to 1 inch or less (www.geostructurs.com). The smallest footers have 6 piers each and the most have 16. All footers and grade beams shall have a compressive strength of 4000 psi and have dimensions ranging from 3' x 3' x 16" to 13' x 13' x 44". The south side of the building, where the bridge portion of the structure meets the hill, has a crawl space consisting of a 4" slab on grade and 12" thick concrete walls.

 

Figure 9, www.geostructures.com

Superstructure:

The north half of the building consists of cast-in-place concrete for all retaining walls, columns, beams, suspended slabs, and slabs on grade. This half of the building houses most of the dining commons and take-out restaurants. The abundance of mechanical piping and ductwork to support the kitchen equipment requires a larger plenum height, which cast in place concrete allows. Floor slab to floor slab height in on level 2 (location of the largest kitchen) is 17’ – 4” with a plenum height of 7’ – 4”, ample room to coordinate overhead systems. The suspended slabs are 9" thick normal weight concrete with 7 1/4" drop panels. Most of the concrete columns are 24" x 24" with 12 #8 reinforcing bars. The elevator and stairwell walls act as 12" thick shear walls reinforced with #5 reinforcing bars at 12" o.c. The slab on grade is 5" thick reinforced with 6"x6" - W2.9 x W2.9 Welded Wire Fabric (WWF). Figure 10 gives the typical concrete strengths.

 
Type
Strength (psi)
Footings, Grade Beams
4,000
Slab on Grade
3,500
Retaining Walls
4,000
Columns, Slabs, and Shear Walls
5,000
Curbs and Equipment Pads
4,000
 
 
Figure 10

When the structure reaches the third floor, the south side of the building spans over Emerson drive. The main structural component for this south section is structural steel; the overhead head mechanical support systems are less dense and therefore require less space than the north section. The steel also has the tensile resistance to span across Emerson Drive, at some points between 40 and 50 feet. On the third floor (the first floor of the bridge) the beams are larger to support the load over the road. Some of the typical beams are W18x35, W21x24, W24x55, and W24x76. The fourth floor beams are more consistent in type, only varying between bays. The four main beams are W10x12, W12x14, W12x19, and W14x22. The steel beams are mostly W12x40's with the occasional W12x45 or 50.The floors are a composite slab structure made up of 3-1/4" light weight concrete reinforced with 6"x6" - W2.1xW2.1 WWF, over a 2", 20 gauge composite steel deck on composite beams. The roof structure for the south end is utilizes 52DLH16 sloped joists with 1-1/2", 20 gauge steel decking.

The roof structure for the south side of the building is made up of 52DLH16 sloped joists with 1-1/2", 20 gauge steel decking. The roof structure where the third floor steps back and the roof structure at the top of the north part of the building is 9" thick normal weight concrete.

Electrical System

West Village Commons will tie into existing campus utilities and provide an outlet to future buildings on the west side of campus. Currently there are three main outdoor switch gears providing 15 kilovolts and 1200 amps each. A new switch gear with the same attributes will feed into a 1500KVA, medium voltage transformer and than into the main switchboard in the basement level. The switchboard is a 277/480 volts, 3-phase, 4-wire with a 2000 amp main breaker. A 150 kilowatt natural gas generator with 277/480 volts, 3-phase, 4-wire, will provide back up energy with in 10 seconds to the commons during a power loss.

The vast amount of kitchen equipment requires a lot of energy and many electrical connections. The complicated electrical system needs close coordination between the electrical contractors and the kitchen equipment vendors. Equipment is constanly changing and the owner will want the most up to date appliances. Changes in locations of connections will have to be carefully tracked.

Lighting System
The lighting system is powered by 277/480 volts, 3-phase, 4-wire power and distributed through 7 different electrical panels throughout the building. Fixtures in the larger rooms are usually fluorescent downlights or 2x2 recessed fluorescent troffers. In other areas with more of an architectural element, there are pendent surfaced mounted lights, wall washers, and decorative pendent lighting. The green roof uses underbench LED lights to allow green roof access at night, while also keeping a focus on the key architectural element.The ornamental stair has floor mounted LED lights providing pleasing touch to highlight the first floor center piece. The lighting in individual rooms utilize dimming switches and occupancy sensors which helps keep energy costs low and gives occupants more control over light.
Mechanical System

Heating Water System:

The hot water system for West Village Commons consists of two packaged cast iron sectional pressureized, wet base water boiler-burners. They run off natural gas and are rated for 3000 MBH. Each weighs approximately 10,000 lbs. They are distrubuted thoughout the building by two 465 gallon per minute pumps located in the basement.

Chilled Water System:

The cold water source is from a chiller located in the basement. The evaporator for the chiller is 3535 MBH with a 565 gpm max flow, and will require 193 kilowatts to power it. The cold water is distributed by two 565 gpm pumps located in the basement. It works together with a closed loop condenser water system which consists of cooling tower located on the roof. The tower is rated as a 300 ton, induced draft counter flow, upblast system, with a 20 horsepower motor and a maximum flow rate of 900 gpm. The condensed water system is distributed by two 900 gpm pumps located in the basement.

HVAC:

The new commons building has an interesting heating, ventilating, and air conditioning system in that it has 7 separate air handling units (AHU) spread throughout the building. They provide hot or cold air to variable air terminal units, allowing greater control in each of the zones. The dining commons kitchen has its own dedicated AHU, and the 3rd and 4th floor are the largest areas supplied by one unit. Greater control means a greater expense in not only material, but also labor and coordination. AHUs 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6 are custom designed air handling units. Figure 11 is a table describing each of the AHU’s.

Unit Designation Type Area Served Unit Location Unit Weight (lbs) CFM
AHU-1
Custom Variable Air Vol.
Meeting Room
Roof
20,500
7,500
AHU-2
Custom Variable Air Vol.
Meeting Room
Roof
20,500
5,000
AHU-3
Custom Variable Air Vol.
Meeting Room
Roof
20,500
7,500
AHU-4
Custom Variable Air Vol.
3rd and 4th Floors
Roof
49,000
25,000
AHU-5
Trane "M" Series Constant Volume
Kitchen
Basement
not specified
6,550
AHU-6
Custom Variable Air Vol.
2nd Floor
Roof
31,000
17,000
AHU-7
Trane "M" Series Variable Air Vol.
1st Floor
1st Floor Mech. Room
not specified
16,000
Figure 11
Fire Suppression/Detection

West Village Commons furnishes a water-based, automatic fire suppression system complete with wet-pipe sprinkler and standpipe system. The system will connect with the domestic water piping to achieve a minimum static pressure of 99 psi. The two stair towers will house the sprinkler risers, where at each landing a sprinkler zone valve is installed. In areas of elevated temperatures such as the large amount of kitchen spaces, high temperature sprinkler heads will be used.

The spinkler system will be coupled with an intelligent reporting fire detection program, NOTIFIER, which is a PC based graphical facilities monitoring system. It will have to power to use floor plans and Closed Caption Television cameras to monitor large areas and report information on non-normal conditions. This program works in conjuction with zoned photoelectric smoke detectors, manual pull stations, annuciating speakers and strobes, and magnetic door holders.

Transportation
The transportation system consists of three elevators: 2 group elevators and 1 service elevator. All three elevators are going to be the Otis Gen-II 200 fpm. The service elevator (elevator "A") has a front and rear opening doorways, and is rated at 4,500 lb max capacity and 200 floors per minutes (fpm). It runs from the basement level to the 4th floor, and is located next to stair tower 1 in the northwest area of the building. The two group elevators (elevators "B & C") have a one side opening, and are rated for 2,500 lb max capacity and 200 fpm. They service only floors 1 through 4, and are located near staircase 2 in the northeast area of the building. All three elevators have a 5'-6" elevator pit with a sump pump, and they are powered by a variable-voltage, variable-frequency, ac-type hoist driven machine.
Food Services

West Village Commons will serve as a student center fully equiped with several dining options. It has already been decided that "Outtakes: Quick Cuisine," "Einstein Bros. Bagels," "Coyote Jack's," and "Jamba Juice" will be the premiere venues of choice (information on some of the restaurants can be found by clicking on their names above). There is also a comprehensive dining commons area equiped with a salad bar, "my pantry," pizza and pasta bar, and a deli. By providing these food services, a large kitchen with special systems needed to be considered in the design. These systems are mainly confined to the first and second floor in the north area of the building, though there is a small coffee shop on the fourth floor.

Level 2 is home to a buffet style dining commons and a large kitchen area to support it. Some of the equipment in the kitchen includes three large walk-in coolers, a walk-in freezer, 2 double-deck ovens, heating shelves, and large hand sinks. The Level 1 tenants will also have access to a walk-in cooler and freezer, smaller appliances to their specifications, and large storage space, some of which is shared between them.

The large kitchen and individual restaurants require multiple ventilation systems and exhaust hoods. There are 11 of these hoods throughout the building that are exhausted with 6 separate exhaust fans. They range from 800 cfm to 8300 cfm and are located on either Level 3 or Level 4 roof. In addition to the exhaust fans, a 2,000 gallon grease interceptor will be installed below grade and connected to all pieces of equipment with grease waste products.